Monday, July 30, 2007
Cliffs and sands but empty hands
So I'm on "vacation" now, spending just three or four days down at a place called Railay beach in Krabi province. This is really the epicenter for climbing, especially beach climbing, in Thailand, which is largely why I came. It's beautiful: the ocean, the sand, the cliffs, the room, everything is very nice. But I'm feeling a bit more lonesome than I did before, probably on account of all the chummy tourists everywhere, but it's nice to be taking a break, and I'll probably be able to get some work done.
The staff at the little bungalow/hotel thing I'm staying at certainly have taken a fast liking to me. It almost seems like they were just sitting around waiting for some Westerner who spoke Thai to show up, because they keep asking me to translate Thai sentences into English that they didn't know how to say before. They also seem to be genuinely happy that there's a tourist who speaks Thai, which is a nice feeling for ol' holier than thou me.
While bouldering around on one of the cliffs this afternoon I did make a friend, an American named B.J. who's from Washington State. He agreed to go with me and his buddy to do some deep water free soloing tomorrow mornign, which should be exciting, to say the least, and is the main reason I am here, to be honest. Let's just hope the weather holds out.
Deep water free soloing is climbing high without a rope on a cliff where there's no chance you would hit anything but water after your fall. Very fun, very un-dangerous. I just wish I was in better climbing shape!
On the bus this morning I got a call from Jiew, on Koh Hlao, who was just wondering where I was, and he told me that they all missed me and that I should come back right away. That was nice. And then Phii Naw called to, and told me she wasn't mad at me and wanted to talk to me before I left and was really worried I was already gone. So there's another interesting conversation that's going to happen.
Ok. Internet here is 10c a minute, so I'm going to keep it relatively short. Keep your shirts tucked in.
Saturday, July 28, 2007
Nobody knows the trouble i've seen
This has been an interesting week. A lot of stuff has happened that I guess I'll tell you about which means I don't get to tell you as many boring old details as those get lost in the fray.
This year, when half the Moken village moved to Elephant Island primarily for fear, helplessness and frustration with Phii Naw herself as I now correctly understand, she went also. The Moken have on numerous occasions referred to this event as Vichay's ‘throwing away of the wife.' I have no idea what actually made her want to leave. Anyways, Vichay evidently has a long history of inviting young girls, usually teenagers, into his house for reading/writing lessons, coffee, and snacks. Usually it has been a single girl (that is, one girl at a time), making repeated visits. See (my consultant) was once one of these girls, and learned to read Thai from Vichay, but now is afraid of him, saying most Moken women don’t trust him, are worried he might rape them. She tells of one incident when she was with him in his house, drinking coffee, and he shut the door, and just looked at her, but she says nothing happened though she knew what he wanted to do, because he was a coward.
When I first started studying linguistics, fieldwork seemed to me to be the ultimate life and academic experience all rolled into one: living with a native people group, trying to work out complex linguistic patterns while seamlessly integrating into their lives. “This is pretty Indiana Jones for a linguist," Jude, the female member of the western couple, said to me on our way to Koh Chang a couple weeks ago, and I shrugged it off but beamed inside.
Still, a lot of questions have been coming up lately that I don’t have good answers to. Like maybe I just don’t belong here--maybe these people really just shouldn’t be seeing white people at all? Am I anything more than a reminder of Western patriarchy and wealth, and while there’s humanity to meet beneath it, and that’s meaningful, do I add anything to their lives that someone else couldn't add just as well? (Does love need to travel?) And is there really a pressing need to understand the complex inner workings of every single language under the sun? Maybe there are just some things we shouldn’t know.
And then there’s me and my life. The Moken live in such close community, brothers, sisters, children, cousins, parents, everyone is around, sometimes under the same roof, often next door, at most a couple islands away. But we are so spread out, and we live through lines and screens, and wait in enormous shiny buildings for the people we love most to come walking out a big shiny door, but we ignore the people on the streets, because we choose our community. Please don't take this as an accusation against anyone, just an observation, and me trying to share a sense that I'm feeling that despite how much we have in a country like America, maybe there's just as much that we don't have.
Sunday, July 22, 2007
These titles are dumb since the date's right there ^
I wake up, usually at around 6:15, always awakened by a rooster cock-a-doodle-doodling and the fierce bubbling of the frying battered bananas in oil across the room. The room is the house of Pa Iat, who is a 50-60ish year old widow who has graciously allowed me to sleep on her floor, with the other five people who sleep on her floor including See my consultant, her two adopted grandkids, and two other teenage guys. It's a split level, and me and the guys sleep above while See and Pa Iat and the kids sleep below. While it costs her nothing despite a dose of hospitality in the form of a mat on the floor and a mosquito smoke ring to do so, she is at least ensured a little business when I wake up, and purchase coffee, a little bowl of stir-fried vermicelli noodles, and sometimes the fried bananas, each for 5B a pop (15c). After I've eaten said items, or sometimes before, I take care of morning sundrie and observe various members of the village walk up to the store and purchase said items for their children or themselves and chat with them, making eloquent and insightful remarks in Moken. (/lakaaw bita/="Where are you going?" /nganyan eng ano-la/='What's your name?', /nyamaan kaa/="Is it delicous?", /nyam ka'/ 'No, thank you, I've already eaten.', /patang ka'/='Thank you again, but really, I'm already full.'). After a while, I'll go bathe.
If there's been a lot of rain, I can just walk across the street, to the hose of Nyora and Yara', where I've been eating, and, using the basins of water filled by the previous night's rain, dump water with a much smaller basin/bowl (English is such a lexically impoverished language!) over my head. You shower clothed in Thailand, which extends culturally to the Moken, I guess. Anyways, bathing clothed various from shirts and pants (See's preferred method) to just your underwear (Jiew's preferred method) to everything in between. I like a pair of shorts, or else my Pakama (sarong), which also facilitates the post-shower clothes change.
One of the beauties of of showering in your underwear is you get to wash your underwear AND your body at the same time, ensuring, effectively, that you'll never run out of underwear, though occasionally a good launder is warranted.
If there hasn't been much rain, as was the case for two or three days this week, the basins empty quickly, and you resort to Plan B. Plan B is a small spring-fed cinderblock-ringed basin down the beach, about a 5-10 minute walk away. The springwater can only be reached at mid-to-low tide, and there is often a line when you arrive. The water feeds into the spring slowly, about like a faucet half turned on, and you often have to stand around admiring the scenery before you get to bath and enjoy your walk back to the village, air drying all the way.
Admiring the scenery for the most part involves visually inspecting the diverse and colorful piles of trash that have been washed up by the previous high tide, as well as admiring the kaleidoscopic plastic bags on the lower branches of the mangroves. You can also admire the natural beauty of the beach, sea, forest, and crabs, once the trash has lost its fleeting appeal.
After bathing and walking back, sometimes inspecting peoples various net catches and chatting a bit, I'll either start doing fieldwork for a little bit, which I'll get to in a second, or eat morning rice (one of two ricings). They always wait for me to eat, probably just because I'm a guest to be polite. They've been making very good food for me since I've been there, and I've been helping them pay a bit too, after consulting See. I give about B100, which probably covers a significant portion of it which is good since somewhere around nine people almost always eat at Yara's house besides me, including Yara' and Nyowa, the married couple who built the house, their three kids Dinda ~11?, Enen ~8?, and Sude~5? (the youngest and oldest being girls), also Sali, who I don't think has a father and is about Enen's age, Tatam, who is Yara's cousin, Yara's parents, Ebap Ngore and Ebum Liye', and See, my consultant, who is married and has a kid with Yara's brother, Puket, who is currently in prison in the Nicobar Islands.
Anyways, I think I'm going to make a big grocery shopping trip tomorrow before heading back to the island instead of the cash gifts, at See's suggestion, who is excellent informing me of what is culturally expected of me at any given moment. Because I'm there, they make a lot of dishes, and I have to try all of them, and they're almost always good, and I haven't been sick once.
The food is eaten sitting on the ground on the porch of the house around a small table, probably 10 inches off the ground, which can be moved around. This is common throughout southeast Asia, or at least in Thailand, I believe. The Moken eat with their hands, like lots of people in the world, but when I ate my first meal on Hlao Island everyone at the table was eating with spoons, Ngore rather maladroit-and-sheepishly. Knowing that they prefer to eat with their hands, I decided the only way to help them get over their hand-eating anxiety was to eat with my hands, which I did (and which is fun buta little messy). After insisting that I actually eat with my spoon once or twice, and me ignoring their insistence, I was pleased to see that in the following meals those who wanted to resumed eating with their hands. So that was good. After I eat, there's a basin of water at the table which I drink a big drink from after washing my hands with, and that's it.
Despite See's insistence that I eat with her in-laws, and the completely overwhelming hospitality which they've offered and continue to extend to me, I know there must be countless times in a day when I destroy some cultural taboo or another despite my best efforts and sensitivity. Sometimes even the most backwards behavior which initially seems destructive can be later seen to play a socially important role. I'm specifically thinking of the whole matter of resource sharing and asking, or demand sharing. A couple days ago, when See was at a meeting with some Moken talking to the governor of Ranong, I cracked open Acarn N.'s dissertation on the Moken and read.
"It is widely accepted that the pattern of distribution among foragers is characterized by voluntary sharing. This form of sharing is sometimes called "unsolicited giving", in contrast to the other form of sharing which is achieved by asking or demanding."
Of this other form of sharing, Narumon writes: "Unlike voluntary sharing, "demand sharing" is generally instigated from the assertion of the potential recipients instead of being initiated by the donor-contrubutors...The concept of "demand sharing" and "begging" has not been led into broad anthropological discussion. According to Peterson (1993:869) 'it has been neglected because off the particular ethical construction that Westerners place on generosity -- that of outwardly unsolicited and altruistic giving.'"
Interesting!
She goes on: "Demand sharing is an essential part of the levelling mechanism which contributes to the maintenance of egalitarianism and conservatism among most foragers, because 'Demand sharing clearly makes accumulation difficult.' (Peterson again)...The philosophy of demand sharing is actually a reverse of 'keeping up with the Jonses.' In Western capitalistic societies, the accumulation of wealth and prestige is encouraged, and people compete to hve at least as much as their neighbors or peers. In foraging societies, the principle of the sharing rules, and wealth is brought down and shared among others as an effective form of redistribution."
And then finally:
"N. Peterson (1993:864) investigates demand sharing among the Australian Abirigines and puts forth an interesting finding -- demand sharing actually relieves the potential givers of the responsibility to decide with whom to share surplus...Peterson suggests further that '...demands can be refused. This can usually be done only by hiding, secretive behavior, and lying (1993: 864). These three strategies do not work well in foraging societies where everyone knows so much about everyone else...Demand sharing works as a repetitive reinforcement of the obligation to give."
Narumon goes on to discuss four "levels" of demand sharing, the most affable of which is "Indirect demand sharing: complaint and question."
There's no saying the extent to which an outsider can actually participate in this system. I might actually be wrong in projecting myself as being a part of their community and necessarily within their cultural rules. But it does seem, at least, that they have been considering me stingy for not giving them the small gifts when they ask for them, especially to older, or less fortunate members of the community.
My earlier approach had been to not spend any money myself, attempting to find solidarity by faking poverty, but "Service (1966:14) suggests that 'economizing' is not a common practice among foragers; 'they admire generosity, they expect hospitality, they punish thrift as selfishness." There was an incident on Monday where I went to this little event at the library that had been put on where there was a little Art Exhibit of pictures that had been taken on Koh Hlao and the kids danced a little bit to these funny little cute songs. A guy I was with, Phenat, asked me to buy him some chicken on a stick, because I didn't have any money. I refused, because I wasn't going to plan on any myself, planning on "dinner when I get home" and what not. But my behavior, in retrospect, was miserly in Moken eyes. I clearly had the money, and I should have bought him, and me, and whoever wanted it, chicken on a stick. I need to realize that I'm not fooling anybody, and 10B chicken purchases and B20 handouts won't make me go broke, and that God loves a cheerful giver.
While I had earlier been feeling like there were these few pesky individuals in the community who kept talking about how little they had, thinking that those individuals where just complainers and liked handouts. Instead, I realized (and talked to See about this too), that they actually do have it really hard right now (duh) and they are working well within their cultural framework of identifying a community member with the capacity and resources to help them, temporary as it may be (yours truly). They usually make modest requests (20-30 baht). Some of them, and I'm talking about older women here, clearly drink, but I am beginning to feel that this doesn't necessarily warrant my refusing them money. I talked to See about this, and she said while I didn't have to give them something, it certainly wouldn't be a problem if I did. So I gave someone who was going on about how she didn't have any fish or soup B20, and that was that.
Scaling this up, there have still been a couple of really informal requests for nets that I've thought maybe I should make at least partial contributions towards, maybe in the $30-50 range, or something like that. I've learned since my original request that the nets can be bought piecemeal, one 'head' at a time, and as few as three to five heads can serve as effective for fishing. So I've been contemplating making more minor net "donations", more in the B1000 range, to people to come ask for them, but not planning any large scale distribution, as these top-down approaches tend to lead to disaster. The Moken's nets are frequently stolen by the Thais (like, one was just stolen yesterday), and I feel really bad because I clearly have the ability to help a bit. While I've since come to realize that many of the Moken aren't as impoverished as I initially thought, I've also come to realize that because of that there won't be a desperate rush for equal compensation when I grant someone's request for a small gift, and that an answer as simple as "he asked first and I don't have enough anymore" is enough to ward of ensuing requests, again as a result of observing their behavior. Anyways...
After morning rice, I usually begin my fieldwork, which lasts on the good days for a full four hours. The fieldwork is a chore but occasionally enourmously rewarding, and See is a great informant, as she likes just sitting around naturally, is very smart, and has a good sense of humor. The ideal place we've found to do work is actually on the front porch of a house built by Action Aid, a British relief organization. The house is one of the furthest out in the water, and affords both an excellent view of the days activities taking place around us, as well as a constant, cool breeze.
One of See's (therefore my) favorite recent activities has been the 'fake conversation', where in I have a conversation with someone taking out their boat or living in one of the next houses over. Yelled conversations are very frequent among the Moken. The game involves me yelling something in Moken after See tells me what to say and laughs hysterically after I say it. The game has the advantage of first giving the Moken an impression that I speak excellent Moken while simultaneously relieving me of the stress of saying something culturally appropriate. The more mild conversations simply involve someone going out in their boat to drop their nets, and me asking about what they're looking for, etc. I never want to say what See wants me to say, but she always insists I say it while laughing. Remember that this is See speaking through me. Some examples:
Me: "Hey! What are you doing!"
Neighbor: "I'm making a treat for the kids!"
Me: "How many kids do you have!" (Knowing she has a lot)
Neighbor: "Six!"
Me: "Why do you have so many kids!"
Neighbor: "The Lord gave them to me!"
Me: "Lies!"
*Uproarious laughter ensues*
(Note: this is not intended as a religious slam, I don't think, but rather the Moken version of a somewhat dirty joke.)
Another:
Me: "Hey! What are you doing!"
Guy sitting in boat: "Drinking!"
Me: "Why?!"
Guy in boat: "Because I don't have any money!"
Me: "Lies!! How do you buy your liquor!?"
Guy in boat: ...somethng I don't understand, but I'm supposed to say...
Me: "You're are bad!" (uproarious laughter)
Guy in boat: ...something else I don't understand...
Me: "You are a bad person!!" (more uproarious laughter)
Or simply:
Me: "Where are you going!"
Guy leaving in boat: "To drop my nets!"
Me: "What have you been catching?"
Guy: "Nothing. And I have no money."
Me: "Lies!!" (uproarious laughter)
You probably see the pattern. Remember that See is dictating my words. At least they all seem to be pretty light hearted, and these conversations have actually been enormously constructive culturally. The Moken are far less reserved than almost any other aisian culture I know. This isn't really that surprising, but it makes me feel much less social anxiety. If I do somthing wrong, they'll tell me, and if they want something, they'll let me know.
After fieldwork, I'll walk around a little, chat with different people, and eat evening rice, usually at around five, sometimes after a second bath. Around nightfall, the generator goes on, and the TV's all do do. I usually sit in Nara's house, my computer plugged in, and do work while watching the TV. At around nine I put the computer away, and go over to Pa Iat's house, where I go to bed.
***
I realize now that before this week I saw the Moken as characters in some sort of cultural play. Instead, obviously, they're people with names and children who eat food, cuddle with their kids, brush their teeth, and watch T.V. I had thought that in order to enter into commmunity with the Moken I had to somehow earn their trust, prove to them how culturally sensitive or fair I was, or learn to speak Moken really well. I have found this week that community is much simpler than that. You just tell them about yourself and listen to their stories, and share your time. It now seems so simple that I feel dumb saying it, but while it can be hard to get there, once you meet someone in simple relation, the artifices of culture and fear disappear, and that's it.
Today, I went to Acarn Sien's church and Pa Iat with her adopted grandson and Ebum Liye' came in, the only two, and came up and sat in my aisle, near the front. Ebum leaned over and asked if I was coming back to Koh Hlao that day, and I said no, and she asked why, and I told her I had to do a visa run to Burma (which has now been done successfully). After church I sat with them and ate the meal, and chatted in Moken, me speaking poorly, of course. (Still, they always seem to prefer even a bad Moken conversation to a good Thai one and continue to think I understand everything their saying.) I don't think I had any better friends there today than them. I took the little truckbus back towards the pier with them, and paid their fare and gave them some money for gas on the way back, and said "I'm going now" in Moken, and that was it.
Sunday, July 15, 2007
Sunday, July 8, 2007
Wednesday, July 4, 2007
Week 2, Wednesday: Enter Mokenland
I've finished three days of fieldwork and it's going ok. Because I'm focused really on just two topics this trip, the aforementioned lack of preparation hasn't been as stressful as I thought it would. I can really stretch out the sessions and go over the same data to be sure, which I need to do anyways. This probably doesn't mean much to you so I'll just saying it's going ok and I'm hopeful for the prospects.
The situation with the Moken hasn't changed, really. The pastor in Ranong, who's a bit of a lone ranger when it comes to aid (that is, he doesn't really communicate at all with other organizations trying to assist the Moken), raised some money and had some Campus Crusaders (including former childhood friend of Erica and hubster, I believe) go build a whole villiage on the next island out (30 houses and a church), which is called Koh Chang translated meaning Elephant Island though I don't think there are any there. This is because the island is reasonably far from shore, like an hour or 45 minutes or something, and I don't think elephants can swim that far. It also costs the Moken a lot more money to go from there to the town and back, and with the rising world-market prices of fossil fuels it's not totally clear that the situation out on Elephant Island is necessarily an improvement. There was some persuasion involved in moving the Moken to Elephant, island, as 30 families did, inin the form of a big bag of rice, so they're ok for a while I guess, but the place is much harder to find foods such as clams and stuff which are nice because you can just pick them up on the beach and all. This is because their old place was near a whole series of tidal estuaries and the ocean was much shallower and closer to shore, making it an ideal ecosystem for clam-type invertebrates. They're making money, I think, finishing building a church for the pastor out there, but it's not clear what will happen when they're done. This is a much longer story than I have time to tell right now, though.
What is worth saying, and I'll probably mention it again, is that a lot of the Moken living on Ko' Hlao have lost or have never had crab nets. Crab nets are an ideal way to feed yourself and make some extra money on a daily basis, and it's amazing to me that despite all the aid and attention that the Moken have gotten here, a lot of them are still netless. It seems that this is a relatively obvious way to help people make a decent living on their own, and it's a sustainable investment at that. There's between 5-10 families without nets. I've decided I'd like to do something about it myself, and it'd be great if you could help, actually. A net isn't cheap, about $200, but it's basically a way of giving a family food and also a very direct way of redistributing those resources which we Americans have in such abundance. I'm hoping to buy two or three myself, and if anyone would like to chip in and buy part of or all of another net, please send me an email and let me know how much you'd like to donate. This is purely a favor and an act of goodwill, and please feel absolutely no obligation to help out. We can figure out the money later, but I can just buy the nets myself for now. I'm going to talk to the Moken about this and see what they think, but I wanted to put the idea out there so you all could start thinking about it. All the money will go straight to the nets, no service charge or nothing.
Right now, I'm at this office of an organization of some Thai volunteers who I met who are having a big fiesta out on the Moken island (the old one, Koh Hlao). Anyways, there's a little girl here who walked up to me and stuck out her hand and I shook it and she walked away. She came back in and looked at my phone. She told me that my phone was like her mom's. She looked at my cheap $8 watch and asked me how much it cost. I told her B200. She told me it was expensive. She calls me Farang (which is what Thais call Westerners) and told me that she met someone named Farang once before.
Ok. I've got to go. I'll write more on the weekend. I put some pictures on the picasa site that you can get to by clicking the old pictures, I think.
Sunday, July 1, 2007
Week 1, Sunday: Ranong, at night
The bus ride down from Bangkok was uneventful, for the most part. It left at 8:20PM and got in at 5:30AM and I walked to the church, which took about 20 minutes, and then had to wait at a restaurant that was just opening outside for an hour before they opened the gate. I slept on the bus but lost my cell phone...who knows how. Possibly my fault, possibly not. I wasn't careful enough, either way. I've already got a new phone with at new number, though, if you're interested in calling me via Skype (Sarah says it costs you about 12 cents a mintue): 08-1397-5133. I had trouble with my last phone making international calls and I'm wondering now if it was because I was trying to call cell phones. So if you want to call, you're more than welcome, and I'll answer at almost any time, and I'll evidently still have good reception at all the islands I'll be going to over the next month. (crazy, huh?) I'm 11 hours ahead of the east coast time.
It's good to be back in Ranong, but it's always such a drastic change from Bangkok. I'm going from a megacity that's totally westernized to the smallest provicial capital in Thailand, and there's 76 of them. It's a totally different feel, needless to say. I think I'm starting out on a much better leg than last time, though. Last year I was relatively shell shocked at this point, and thought I needed to start the work immediately (like the morning I arrived) and wasn't fully prepared for all the complexities of the situation here with the church and everything, which I might write about more but I know I've talked with a lot of you about.
The good news is that everyone who knew me is glad to see me again. I start my fieldwork tomorrow. I'm actually feeling a little overwhelmed and underprepared right now, that said, so I won't write for too much longer. Despite my days of preparation for the last few months, I've still managed to put off the last crucial steps of preparation in planning out each day and getting specific sentences ready for each of them, which means I have the double duty of analysis and preparation on many upcoming days, which probalby means I'll get far less done, sadly. Hopefully some will be enough, though.
I love you all and hope things are going well. More pictures will come soon.